in indiana can a patient use a incident report for a hospital malpractice suit

by Paige Anderson 6 min read

Reporting a Doctor or Hospital for Medical Malpractice

10 hours ago No. It is critical to understand that filing a report does not initiate a medical malpractice lawsuit, nor does it automatically help to establish medical negligence in any case you do eventually file. A report filed with the state board can only affect the ability of the doctor or hospital to continue practicing medicine. >> Go To The Portal


No. It is critical to understand that filing a report does not initiate a medical malpractice lawsuit, nor does it automatically help to establish medical negligence in any case you do eventually file. A report filed with the state board can only affect the ability of the doctor or hospital to continue practicing medicine.

Full Answer

What happens when a patient files a medical malpractice report?

When a patient files a report with a state medical complaint board, the doctor or hospital (along with an associated insurance company) will be informed. The insurance company may view the report as the precursor to a medical malpractice lawsuit, and it might offer the patient money to settle the issue.

When to write incident reports in hospitals?

Usually, nurses or other hospital staff file the report within 24 to 48 hours after the incident occurred. The outcomes improve by recording incidents while the memories of the event are still fresh. When To Write Incident Reports in Hospitals? When an event results in an injury to a person or damage to property, incident reporting becomes a must.

What is a patient incident report (pair)?

A patient incident report, according to Berxi, is “an electronic or paper document that provides a detailed, written account of the chain of events leading up to and following an unforeseen circumstance in a healthcare setting.” Reports are typically completed by nurses or other licensed personnel.

Is a hospital incident report a Quality Care Control report?

On appeal to the Supreme Court of Virginia, the hospital objected to the trial court admitting the incident report into evidence, claiming that the report was a 'Quality Care Control Report' (QCCR), part of the hospital's quality control process, and, therefore, privileged and exempt from disclosure under the states' peer review statutes. 1,2.

Hospitals Are Liable For Employee Actions

If someone is an employee of a hospital, the hospital is typically responsible (liable) if that employee hurts a patient by acting incompetently. I...

Is The Doctor An Employee of The Hospital?

This is the critical question when figuring out whether the hospital itself can be sued when a doctor provides sub-standard care and ends up causin...

Exceptions: When Hospitals Are Liable For Non-Employee Doctors' Actions

Even if a hospital would generally not be liable for an independent contractor doctor's malpractice, a hospital may be held responsible in certain...

What is an incident in healthcare?

An incident is an unfavourable event that affects patient or staff safety. The typical healthcare incidents are related to physical injuries, medical errors, equipment failure, administration, patient care, or others. In short, anything that endangers a patient’s or staff’s safety is called an incident in the medical system.

Who is responsible for filing incident reports?

The busiest hospital personnel, nurses, and doctors are mainly responsible for filing incident reports. Due to their busy and often overworked schedule, they sometimes fail to report incidents. A solution must factor in this constraint at the time of design and implementation to ensure all incidents are recorded in a timely fashion without over-burdening the staff.

Why is incident reporting important?

Improving patient safety is the ultimate goal of incident reporting. From enhancing safety standards to reducing medical errors, incident reporting helps create a sustainable environment for your patients. Eventually, when your hospital offers high-quality patient care, it will build a brand of goodwill.

How does predictive analytics improve healthcare?

Using predictive analysis, healthcare facilities can improve the quality of patient care and reduce workplace mishaps. Around 60% of healthcare leaders have confirmed that adopting predictive analytics has improved their efficiency considerably.

What is clinical risk management?

Clinical risk management, a subset of healthcare risk management, uses incident reports as essential data points. Risk management aims to ensure the hospital administrators know their institution performance and identify addressable issues that increase their exposure.

What are near miss incidents?

#2 Near Miss Incidents 1 A nurse notices the bedrail is not up when the patient is asleep and fixes it 2 A checklist call caught an incorrect medicine dispensation before administration. 3 A patient attempts to leave the facility before discharge, but the security guard stopped him and brought him back to the ward.

How much of healthcare is wasted?

Even the World Health Organisation (WHO) has estimated that 20-40% of global healthcare spending goes waste due to poor quality of care. This poor healthcare quality leads to the death of more than 138 million patients every year. Patient safety in hospitals is in danger due to human errors and unsafe procedures.

How long does it take to file a patient incident report?

Patient incident reports should be completed no more than 24 to 48 hours after the incident occurred.

How long after incident should you report a patient?

Patient incident reports should be completed no more than 24 to 48 hours after the incident occurred. You may even want to file the report by the end of your shift to ensure you remember all the incident’s important details. RELATED: Near Miss Reporting: Why It’s Important.

Why is it important to review patient incidents?

Reviewing incidents helps administrators know what risk factors need to be corrected within their facilities , reducing the chance of similar incidents in the future.

Why is 62 percent of incidents not reportable?

Staff did not consider 62 per cent of incidents as reportable, due to unclear incident reporting requirements. Because of this, the first step to incident management in any healthcare facility is writing strong, clear reporting requirements. Then, staff can submit reports that help correct problems of all types.

Why do we use resolved patient incident reports?

Using resolved patient incident reports to train new staff helps prepare them for real situations that could occur in the facility. Similarly, current staff can review old reports to learn from their own or others’ mistakes and keep more incidents from occurring. Legal evidence.

What to include in an incident report?

Every facility has different needs, but your incident report form could include: 1 Date, time and location of the incident 2 Name and address of the facility where the incident occurred 3 Names of the patient and any other affected individuals 4 Names and roles of witnesses 5 Incident type and details, written in a chronological format 6 Details and total cost of injury and/or damage 7 Name of doctor who was notified 8 Suggestions for corrective action

Why is it important to document an incident?

Even if an incident seems minor or didn’t result in any harm, it is still important to document it. Whether a patient has an allergic reaction to a medication or a visitor trips over an electrical cord, these incidents provide insight into how your facility can provide a better, safer environment.

What happens when a patient files a medical complaint?

The insurance company may view the report as the precursor to a medical malpractice lawsuit, and it might offer the patient money to settle the issue. A patient should be very hesitant ...

What is the purpose of a medical malpractice lawsuit?

On the other hand, the purpose of a lawsuit for medical malpractice is to get compensation for harm caused by a mistake by a doctor or hospital. Such a lawsuit must be filed in court, and patients should usually consult an attorney before initiating the process.

What is the purpose of filing a complaint with a state medical complaint board?

The purpose of filing a report with a state’s medical complaint board is to provide the professional medical community with information that a doctor or hospital is not meeting the standards of the profession.

Why is a doctor's report important?

However, the report is still important because if the board receives a similar complaint about the same doctor in the near future, the board might be much more likely to sanction the doctor.

Where do you report medical errors?

All medical errors should be reported to a state’s medical complaint board. The process of filing a report and the subsequent proceedings vary significantly by state. In general, the patient will fill out a form identifying all of the relevant parties and describing the mistake that occurred, as well as any harm that resulted from it.

Why is it important to report health care errors?

It is important that problems be properly reported so that regulatory boards can reduce the likelihood of future errors by creating solutions to common treatment mishaps ...

Can a patient sue for medical malpractice?

Once the offer is accepted, the patient will no longer be able to sue for medical malpractice over the incident, since the signing of a release of rights would be part of the deal. If unsure, the most prudent course of action in this situation is to contact a medical malpractice attorney.

Who is responsible for hurting a patient?

Under a time-tested legal theory known as " respondeat superior ," if someone is an employee of a hospital, the hospital is typically responsible (liable) if that employee hurts a patient by acting incompetently.

What happens if a hospital employee is negligent?

In other words, if the employee is negligent (is not reasonably cautious when treating or dealing with a patient), the hospital will usually be on the hook for any resulting harm to the patient. (Keep in mind that not every mistake or unfortunate event that happens in a hospital rises to the level of negligence.

What is a hospital responsible for?

A number of states hold the hospital responsible if the facility gives staff privileges to an incompetent or dangerous doctor, even if the doctor is an independent contractor. The hospital can also be responsible if it should have known that a previously safe doctor had become incompetent or dangerous. For example, if a doctor is abusing alcohol ...

Is a hospital responsible for medical malpractice?

Though hospitals are often on the hook for incompetent care provided by employees like nurses and medical technicians, they often are not responsible for a doctor's medical negligence. Let's take a closer look at when a hospital is (and is not) responsible for medical malpractice committed by employees, doctors, anesthesiologists, ...

Can a hospital employee sue a doctor?

Also, if a hospital employee commits malpractice while under a doctor's supervision, the patient can sue the doctor, but the hospital may be off the hook. Whether an employee is under the supervision of the doctor when the misdeed occurs depends on: whether the doctor was present, and. whether the doctor had sufficient control over ...

Can a hospital be liable for a mistake?

However, if a doctor makes a mistake and injures a patient while working in the hospital, the hospital will not be liable for the doctor's mistake unless the doctor is an employee (which is unlikely; see below). Also, if a hospital employee commits malpractice while under a doctor's supervision, the patient can sue the doctor, ...

Is a doctor an employee of a hospital?

Hospitals attempt to avoid this problem by informing patients in the admission forms that the doctor is not a hospital employee. The situation is different for patients injured in an emergency room. Usually, the hospital does not have an opportunity to inform emergency room patients that a doctor is not an employee.

Why is it important to bring all potentially responsible parties to a medical malpractice suit?

It is critical that all potentially-responsible parties be brought to the suit, because it may not be possible to go back later to add a party. 7. Comply With any Procedural Rules. Many states require patients to jump through a few hoops before filing medical malpractice lawsuits.

What happens when a hospital makes a mistake?

When a hospital makes a mistake that rises to the level of medical malpractice, a patient has a legal right to receive compensation for any resulting injuries. While medical malpractice laws are designed to protect the rights of patients who have been subjected to substandard medical care, the first step in asserting those rights must be taken by ...

What is the statute of limitations for medical malpractice?

1. Act Before The Statute of Limitations Deadline Passes. The biggest mistake a patient can make is waiting too long to file a medical malpractice lawsuit in court. Statutory time limits (called "statutes of limitations" in legalese) require patients to file legal claims promptly.

How long do hospitals keep medical records?

A hospital must keep every patient's medical records for at least a few years after treatment . Upon request, the hospital must give copies of the records to the patient (however, the hospital may charge a fee for copying expenses).

Is a medical malpractice case a legal action?

A medical malpractice case isn't the kind of legal action you want to try handling on your own. These cases can get very complex from a legal, medical, and procedural standpoint. Proving your case is going to require not just a firm understanding of the law as it applies to your situation, but a familiarity with the kinds of hoops a medical malpractice plaintiff needs to jump through, including the retention of the right expert medical witness.

Do medical malpractice lawyers get paid?

Medical malpractice lawyers generally offer free initial consultations. Most rely on contingency fee agreements. Under this arrangement, if the lawyer settles or wins the case, the law firm takes a portion (usually about 1/3) of the award. If the lawyer loses the case, the lawyer usually is not paid, though the client may be on the hook for certain costs.

Do hospitals give copies of records?

Upon request, the hospital must give copies of the records to the patient (however, the hospital may charge a fee for copying expenses). 5. Determine Your Damages. At some point, the hospital might make an offer to settle the case. So, it is important for the patient to determine the value of the case.

Why are incident reports not privileged?

In summary, the Virginia Supreme Court held that incident reports presented to the hospital's quality control committee were not privileged under the states' peer review statutes because they were factual information collected in the ordinary course of business and operations of the hospital. 1.

When should an incident report be shared?

Only prepare an "incident report" when no harm came to the patient and litigation is not even remotely expected. If the patient incurred injury as a result of an incident, or the hospital staff believe litigation is possible, then the information should be shared only with the hospital attorney's office.

Why did the hospital retain the QCCR?

However, in this case the hospital retained the QCCR describing Johnson's fall specifically because it anticipated litigation would ensue, and it argued that the information on the QCCR was a 'qualitative analysis' of Johnson's fall that should be protected by the statute. The plaintiffs claimed the QCCR did not contain any qualitative information about the incident, only the 'factual circumstances' of the fall. 1

Why were occurrence screens protected from discovery?

The hospital argued that its occurrence screens were protected from discovery under the attorney-client privilege because they were made in anticipation of litigation, stating:

What did Scott's mother sue for?

Scott's mother sued the hospital in state court under the Emergency Medical Treatment and Active Labor Act (EMTALA). 12 She claimed that the hospital failed to stabilize her son's emergency medical condition (EMC), failed to provide medical treatment to minimize his risks of transfer, failed to certify in writing as required by the law that the benefits of transfer outweighed the risks of transfer (which the defendant admitted), 13 and transferred him in an unstable condition in violation of the act. 11 She also filed a state law claim for professional negligence against the trauma surgeon for failing to take her son to the operating room to stop his bleeding and for transferring him in an unstable condition. The hospital removed the case out of state court into federal district court. 11,14

Why was the occurrence screen not privileged?

The plaintiffs contended that the occurrence screen was not privileged because such reports are prepared routinely and in the ordinary course of business. 8

What is Long v. Women and Infant Hospital?

Women and Infant Hospital of Rhode Island.7 In this wrongful death action, the plaintiff parents filed a motion to compel the hospital to produce an occurrence screen that was prepared by a nurse after their prematurely-born son died during treatment in the hospital's neonatal intensive care unit.

What is Hospital Malpractice and Can I Sue?

Attorneys Fred Pritzker and Eric Hageman and their award-winning legal team have decades of experience successfully representing clients.

Hospital Lawsuit Information

If someone you love has been harmed, here is some important information that you should consider:

Our Law Firm and Lead Malpractice Lawyer Fred Pritzker

Because of the time, cost and complexity of hospital malpractice cases, good law firms carefully review potential hospital malpractice claims. Here’s how our process works. In response to a hospital malpractice inquiry, one of our staff will conduct a free telephone consultation.

What is medical malpractice?

Most medical malpractice cases proceed under the theory that a medical professional was negligent in treating the patient. To establish medical negligence, an injured patient, the plaintiff, must prove: The existence of a duty owed by the health care professional to the plaintiff (for example, a doctor/patient relationship); ...

How to find a medical professional negligent?

To find a medical professional negligent, it must be shown that his or her conduct fell below a generally accepted standard of medical care. To establish the standard to be applied, a plaintiff must present the testimony of another medical expert, qualified in the same area of medicine as the defendant, indicating what standard, or level of care, is commonly met by those recognized in the profession as being competent and qualified to practice. The plaintiff will have to present expert testimony not only as to this standard of care, but also show the defendant failed to meet this standard.

What is the law of res ipsa loquitur?

If a patient injured as the result of a medical procedure does not know exactly what caused his or her injury, but it is the type of injury that would not have occurred without negligence on the part of his or her health care provider (s), he or she may invoke a legal doctrine known as " res ipsa loquitur ." Translated, this Latin phrase means "the thing speaks for itself," and implies that the plaintiff only needs to show that a particular result occurred and would not have occurred but for someone's negligence.

What is a negligent prescription?

Negligent Prescription of Medications or Medical Devices. A medical professional may be held liable for the negligent prescription of a medication or medical device if he or she ignored the manufacturer's instructions, or prescribed an incorrect medication or dosage, which resulted in injury to the patient.

Why is it so hard to prove malpractice?

Proving malpractice is also difficult because the defendants are often the ones who write the medical reports that may form the basis of the suit.

What is the failure to obtain informed consent?

In many situations, the failure to obtain a patient's " informed consent " before administering a procedure or treatment is a form of medical negligence, and may even give rise to a cause of action for battery. Although the specific definition of informed consent may vary from state to state, it essentially means that a physician (or other medical provider) must tell a patient all of the potential benefits, risks, and alternatives involved in any surgical procedure, medical procedure, or other course of treatment, and must obtain the patient's written consent to proceed.

Who had exclusive control of the instrumentality that caused the injury?

The defendant, or its employees or agents, had exclusive control of the instrumentality that caused the injury; and