patient confidentiality can be broken if necessary to report suspected abuse

by Gunner Gutmann 8 min read

When Can Client Confidentiality be Broken? - TheraNest

14 hours ago  · Because many states have mandatory reporting of suspected child abuse, the therapist’s judgment is more constrained in these cases. Ensuring the health of the client is the biggest concern, which means the therapist may want to consult the client regarding how to breach confidentiality regarding abuse when it is legally obligated so as to ensure the client … >> Go To The Portal


If, in the course of therapy, you say something to your therapist that lets her know that there is suspected elder or child abuse happening, the therapist must break confidentiality and report it. Therapists are mandated reporters, meaning that they are legally required to ensure a report is made when abuse is observed or suspected.

Full Answer

Can you breach a patient’s confidentiality if they pose a risk?

Can you breach a patient’s confidentiality if you believe they pose a risk to others? Doctors have a duty of confidentiality to their patients, but they also have a wider duty to protect the health of the public. Marika Davies explains the GMC’s updated guidance on confidentiality

Should therapists break confidentiality when their clients express violent thoughts?

Notably, many depressed clients may express suicidal thoughts. Likewise, many clients with anger issues may express violent thoughts. The fact a client has merely expressed these thoughts in the context of seeking help for them is not cause to breach confidentiality. Instead, the standard which many therapists use is the prospect of intent.

Can confidential patient information be disclosed without the consent of the patient?

We start from the basic position that adults with capacity are usually in the best position to understand how to promote their own interests and ordinarily, confidential patient information should not be disclosed without the consent of the patient. Some exceptions to this are discussed below.

When to consult a medico-legal representative about patient confidentiality?

When a disclosure is contemplated, each case must be considered on its own merits. In such cases, it is advisable to consult with senior colleagues, your hospital legal representative or local Caldicott guardian, or medical defence union. None declared. This article summarizes the main medico-legal issues involving patient confidentiality.

Can patient confidentiality can be broken if necessary to report suspected abuse?

Patient confidentiality can be broken, if necessary, to report suspected abuse. Only health care professionals who work in office environments or highly technical occupations are likely to use computers in their work.

Can doctor-patient confidentiality be broken?

A breach of doctor-patient confidentiality can be considered malpractice; therefore, inappropriate disclosures of information can be grounds for a medical malpractice lawsuit. Depending on how atrocious the disclosure was, it may be possible to recover compensatory damages for the consequences of the breach.

What are the exceptions to doctor-patient confidentiality?

Other legal exceptions to a breach of doctor-patient confidentiality include: Medical treatment of injuries that could relate to criminal conduct (e.g., gunshot wounds, drunk driving, hit and run). Disclosures to the patient's health insurance company for the purposes of getting insurance coverage for treatment.

What are the limits of patient confidentiality?

He or she cannot divulge any medical information about the patient to third persons without the patient's consent, though there are some exceptions (e.g. issues relating to health insurance, if confidential information is at issue in a lawsuit, or if a patient or client plans to cause immediate harm to others).

When can confidentiality be broken?

Breaking confidentiality is done when it is in the best interest of the patient or public, required by law or if the patient gives their consent to the disclosure. Patient consent to disclosure of personal information is not necessary when there is a requirement by law or if it is in the public interest.

When can you breach patient confidentiality?

To provide a simple answer: you may, in certain circumstances, override your duty of confidentiality to patients and clients if it's done to protect their best interests or the interests of the public. This means you may override your duty if: You have information that suggests a patient or client is at risk of harm.

How can confidentiality be breached?

A breach of confidentiality is when private information is disclosed to a third party without the owner's consent. It can happen accidentally to anyone, from a sole trader or freelancer to a small business owner with several employees.

Which of the following is an exception to a patient's right to confidentiality?

Mandatory Exceptions To Confidentiality They include reporting child, elder and dependent adult abuse, and the so-called "duty to protect." However, there are other, lesserknown exceptions also required by law.

What happens if you break patient confidentiality?

If a doctor is found to be guilty they can be charged in court with breaking the law on confidentiality. As a result they risk being 'struck off' the GMC register (and this has happened to many doctors in recent years). Medical students in turn risk expulsion from their medical school.

What are the three limits to confidentiality?

Potential Limits of ConfidentialityLimits Imposed Voluntarily (i.e., Not Legally Required) ... Limits That Can Be Imposed by Law (i.e., Possible “Involuntary” Disclosures) ... Possible Limitations on Confidentiality Created by Use of Technology in the Setting.More items...

What are the two limits to confidentiality?

Two conditions are commonly taken to constitute an obligation of confidentiality: information is entrusted by one person to another; and there is an express understanding that this will not be divulged.

What is the reason for most breaches of confidentiality?

-Most breaches of confidentiality often occur as a result of carelessness and can be avoided through rigorous control over client records by not discussing clients in public areas or with persons who do not have a "need-to-know."

Why do doctors disclose confidential information?

This is the most common reason for revealing confidential details. If the patient expressly consents to disclosure, a doctor is relieved from the duty of confidence. Consent may be explicit or implied. Explicit consent requires active agreement but may be written or oral. It is the preferred form as there is no doubt as to what has been agreed and is usually required for sharing more sensitive data. The patient must have the necessary capacity to consent, that is, understand, retain, and balance the information, and also communicate their decision. This can be challenging in the critical care setting when patients are often sedated or suffering disease processes affecting their conscious level.

Why is confidentiality important in healthcare?

Confidentiality is central to the preservation of trust between doctors and their patients. The moral basis is consequentialist, in that it is to improve patient welfare. There is a wider communitarian public interest in the protection of confidences; thus, preservation of confidentiality is necessary to secure public health. Failure to maintain this venerable obligation may result in suboptimal treatment ( X v Y [1992] 3 BMR 1). For centuries, doctors have upheld this ethical principle underpinned by the Hippocratic Oath that has been updated by the international community assenting to the Declaration of Geneva. The practice of doctors in the UK is subject to the regulatory authority of the General Medical Council (GMC) who strongly uphold this professional duty. The British Medical Association (BMA) advises doctors to consider the benefits of breaching patient confidentiality against the harmful consequences of damaging the professional relationship and risking public trust in a confidential service. 1

What is considered confidential?

The general principles of what is considered confidential have been outlined in common law. A duty of confidence arises when one person discloses information to another (e.g. a patient to a doctor) in circumstances where it is reasonable to expect that the information be held in confidence. To represent a breach, confidential information must: Enforcement of a legal duty in the UK has to date been relatively weak. Both the GMC and Department of Health 3 provide ethical guidance for professionals that would nonetheless be given considerable weighting by the courts or independently lead to professional disciplinary action. There has to date been no criminal conviction of a doctor for breach of confidence, although civil claims in negligence have occurred and damages awarded ( Cornelius v Taranto [2001] 68 BMR 62) when confidence has been breached by revealing medical information without explicit consent.

How many people with HIV are not aware of their diagnosis?

Up to 40% of patients with HIV are not aware of their diagnosis on admission to intensive care. 9 Dealing with a newly diagnosed patient, when they do not have the necessary capacity to permit disclosure of the information to at-risk partners or contact tracing is legally and ethically challenging.

Why is consent form preferred?

It is the preferred form as there is no doubt as to what has been agreed and is usually required for sharing more sensitive data. The patient must have the necessary capacity to consent, that is, understand, retain, and balance the information, and also communicate their decision.

What is the need to know basis for access to personal information?

Access to personal information should be on a strict need-to-know basis. All users and handlers of patient-identifiable data should be aware of their responsibilities. Understand and comply with the law. Justify the purpose of disclosure. Only use patient-identifiable information where absolutely necessary.

What are the characteristics of confidential information?

Characteristics of confidential information 1 - have the necessary quality of confidence, 2 - be imparted in circumstances importing an obligation of confidence, 3 - be disclosed without the permission and to the detriment of the person originally communicating it, 4 - not already be in the public domain, 5 - be in the public interest to protect it.

When did the GMC update its guidance on confidentiality?

1 The revised guidance was written following a consultation with doctors and patients, and will come into effect in April 2017. It sets out a framework for disclosing personal information—including situations in which a disclosure may need to be made to protect people who are at risk of harm.

When should you seek consent from a patient?

In the first instance you should seek consent from your patient to disclose information about them, unless it is not safe or practicable to do so. For example if you have reason to believe that seeking consent would put you or others at risk of serious harm, or if doing so would be likely to undermine the purpose of the disclosure by prejudicing the prevention or detection of serious crime. You should consider any reasons given by the patient if they refuse.

What does the GMC say about disclosure?

Making the disclosure. If it is not practicable or safe to seek consent, or if the patient refuses to give consent, and you are satisfied that information should be disclosed, the GMC says that you should act quickly. You should keep disclosures to the minimum necessary for the purpose.

Why is disclosure justified?

The GMC says that a disclosure may be justified to protect individuals or society from the risk of serious harm, such as from serious communicable diseases or serious crime . For example if the disclosure is likely to be necessary for the prevention, detection, or prosecution of crime, especially crimes against the person.

When deciding if a disclosure is necessary in the public interest, should you consider whether a failure to disclose?

In deciding if a disclosure is necessary in the public interest you should consider whether a failure to disclose would expose others to a risk of death or serious harm. The GMC says that “the benefits to an individual or society of the disclosure must outweigh both the patient’s and the public interest in keeping the information confidential.”.

What age do you have to be to report a genital mutilation?

There are also a number of laws that require doctors to disclose patient information, for purposes including the notification of infectious diseases, the prevention of terrorism, and the reporting of female genital mutilation in girls under the age of 18.

Can a patient tell you something that makes you concerned for the safety of others?

But occasionally a patient will tell you something that makes you concerned for the safety of others. Deciding whether or not to breach confidentiality in these situations can be challenging for doctors, who are mindful of both the importance of trust in the doctor-patient relationship and their wider duty to protect the public.

What is the duty to report child abuse?

The duty to report child abuse is one of the exceptions to the practitioner’s legal and ethical duty of confidentiality. Many situations will arise during the course of a practitioner’s career that will present a question of whether or not a child abuse report must be made. Not all questions are easily resolved, ...

Is it necessary to document a telephone conversation?

Documentation of the telephone conversation, and of the prior research of the question, is of course necessary and wise. If both agree that a report must be made, the practitioner should have no liability for making the report, even if the reported suspicion of child abuse is later found to be unsubstantiated or unfounded.

Physician Encounters with Human Trafficking: Legal Consequences and Ethical Considerations

Physicians caring for trafficking victims should know about applicable criminal and human rights law and mandatory reporting requirements.

What To Do when It Might Be Child Abuse

When a child or family begins to stand out because of patterns in history or physical findings, physicians must determine whether to take a closer look at the situation.

Why is malpractice a problem?

A leading cause of malpractice lawsuits is poor interpersonal relationships between patients and health care providers. It is illegal for the physician who signs a patient's death certificate to participate in any activities that involve removing organs from a deceased patient for transplant in another patient.

What is a breach of contract?

breach of contract. A person, such as an employee, who acts on behalf of another. agent. It is not recommended that a patient be told that he will soon be "as good as new" after suffering a serious heart attack, because the statement may be interpreted as an enforceable.

Can patient confidentiality be broken?

Patient confidentiality can be broken, if necessary, to report suspected abuse.

Is it legal to take organs after death?

It is legal to take organs after a patient's death, without his prior permission or that of his family, if there are patients in the same facility waiting for transplants. As long as a patient gives permission for a procedure, the health care professional is guaranteed protection from charges of battery.

What should health care professionals be familiar with?

Health care professionals should be familiar with the code of ethics for their occupational area in order to:

What is a health care specialist called?

Health care specialists are also referred to as gatekeepers.

What is the major problem with electronic medical records?

A major difficulty with electronic medical records is the inability of various systems to communicate and share information.

What is Medicaid for disabled?

Medicaid is a federal health insurance plan for persons age 65 and older and the disabled.

Where is the shoulder located?

The shoulder is proximal to the elbow.

Can a facility be accused of fraud?

The facility may be accused of fraud

Can insurance companies refuse to pay for services?

Insurance companies can legally refuse to pay for certain services if they are not preauthorized.

What is a 60185?

60185: Advanced Practice Nurse Pharmacology#N#(25 contact hours)#N#Written and rigorously peer reviewed by pharmacists and advanced practice nurses, this course features a wide range of medical conditions and the medications associated with them. Chapter topics include hypertension, diuretics, GI, critical care, sexually transmitted diseases, asthma, oncology, non-opioid analgesics, diabetes, weight loss, mental health conditions and more. APN tips are featured throughout the chapters to help clinicians in their prescribing practices. This course will help APNs meet the new ANCC 25-contact hour pharmacology requirement for recertification.

What happens if a patient breaches confidentiality?

A breach of patient confidentiality can result in a lawsuit. Who is at fault -- and who isn't -- will be determined by the courts based on several factors.

What did the letter to Doe from the President and CEO of the facility informing him of?

A letter was sent to Doe from the president and CEO of the facility informing Doe that an unauthorized disclosure of his confidential health information did occur, appropriate disciplinary action had been taken and steps put into place to prevent such a breach from happening in the future.

What are the topics covered in the APN course?

Chapter topics include hypertension, diuretics, GI, critical care, sexually transmitted diseases, asthma, oncology, non-opioid analgesics, diabetes, weight loss, mental health conditions and more. APN tips are featured throughout the chapters to help clinicians in their prescribing practices. This course will help APNs meet the new ANCC 25-contact hour pharmacology requirement for recertification.

What to do if you are unsure about sharing a patient's information?

2 — If you are unsure about sharing a patient’s information, seek guidance from your nurse manager.

What is the nurse's inaction leading to?

Nurse’s Inaction Leads to Wrongful Death Lawsuit for Hospital

What is the duty of safekeeping a patient's confidential medical information?

The court opined that a medical facility’s duty of safekeeping a patient’s confidential medical information is “limited to those risks that are reasonably foreseeable and to actions within the scope of employment.”

Why is confidentiality important?

Confidentiality is essential to the development of a trusting professional relationship between doctors and patients. It is subject to both legal and ethical safeguards and inappropriate breaches of confidentiality can lead to legal action and to censure by the General Medical Council.

What happens if an abusive partner is interviewed by the police?

If an abusive partner is interviewed by the police or social services for example, abuse may be intensified. The importance of adults who may be at risk of harm being able to control the disclosure of their own information is therefore clear.

Why is disclosure in the public interest justified?

A disclosure in the public interest is likely to be justified where it is essential to prevent a serious and imminent risk to public health, national security, to protect other people from risks of serious harm or death, or to prevent or detect serious crime. Other people here may include, for example, children in the house who may be at risk of serious harm.

Where can information be disclosed?

Most obviously, information can be disclosed where the patient consents to its disclosure. Wherever doctors or other health professionals seek to disclose confidential information about competent adults they should consider in the first instance whether they can obtain consent. Ordinarily, where a competent patient refuses consent to disclosure this should be respected.

What should health professionals ask when contacting police?

If health professionals are contacted by police, social services or their partner organisations and they are uncertain whether disclosure is a statutory requirement, they should ask the person or body applying for the information to specify the nature of their lawful authority.

Why do doctors need to disclose information?

Doctors can also be genuinely concerned that should they fail to disclose information necessary to protect adults at risk of harm, they may be subject to criticism.

What is the right of competent adults?

Competent adults have the right to make decisions about how they manage the risks to which they are exposed. Where health professionals have serious concerns about whether a competent adult who is at risk is being coerced into a decision they should consider taking legal advice about approaching the courts.

Characteristics of Confidential Information

Breaching Patient Confidentiality

  • Inadvertent breaches are potentially commonplace on wards if medical notes are left visible or patient consultations and preoperative assessments are conducted in an open environment. The increased use of computerized documentation results in faster and wider distribution of information with an increased risk of unauthorized access. Unintentional b...
See more on academic.oup.com

Making A Disclosure with The Patient's Consent

  • This is the most common reason for revealing confidential details. If the patient expressly consents to disclosure, a doctor is relieved from the duty of confidence. Consent may be explicit or implied. Explicit consent requires active agreement but may be written or oral. It is the preferred form as there is no doubt as to what has been agreed and is usually required for sharing more s…
See more on academic.oup.com

Statutory Disclosures and Judicial Proceedings

  • If information is required by law, this will not amount to a penalty for a breach. This area can be confusing. It is important for clinicians to be aware that the police do not have automatic powers to demand disclosure nor has a lawyer rights to demand medical information. A court order is required for this purpose. However, a judge can penalize a doctor for contempt of court for failur…
See more on academic.oup.com

Disclosures in The Public Interest

  • Public interest ranges from public health to prevention or detection of serious crime. This justification is more subjective and in contentious cases, the courts may be required to decide. There is a distinction between ‘in the public interest and what the public are interested in’. Consider a scenario where a patient admits to a crime while under the influence of your sedativ…
See more on academic.oup.com

Disclaimer

  • This article summarizes the main medico-legal issues involving patient confidentiality. The authors advise readers to seek formal legal advice if clarification is required.
See more on academic.oup.com