failure to report patient abuse

by Jonathan Barton 5 min read

You suspect a patient is being abused. What should you do?

24 hours ago  · The CFSA states we must report, but Section 72 (7) also protects against liability if civil action is brought against the reporter, as long as there was no malice in reporting. Patient records are confidential & private, but once a suspicion of abuse occurs, our duty to report overrides the provisions of other Statutes such as PHIPA (Personal Health Information … >> Go To The Portal


Some of the reports, however, serve the patient directly, and the failure to report may lead to legal action brought on behalf of the patients who allege harm. Indirectly mandatory child abuse reporting laws serve the public by attempting to reduce the incidence of abuse and thereby protect a sizeable portion of the population, but their main purpose is to protect the patient.

Failure to report is gross misdemeanor.
040 and who knowingly fails to make such report or fails to cause such report to be made is guilty of a gross misdemeanor.

Full Answer

What happens if you fail to report a patient’s abuse?

Some of the reports, however, serve the patient directly, and the failure to report may lead to legal action brought on behalf of the patients who allege harm.

What are the risks of reporting abuse in a nursing home?

Nursing home staff sometimes fear the personal consequences of reporting abuse, which could include: victimisation; intimidation; ostracism; reprisal from peers, managers or employers; and loss of employment (Carvel, 2009; Taylor and Dodd, 2003). 12 nursing or care staff.

What are the rules for reporting patient abuse in Massachusetts?

Massachusetts General Law, Chapter 111, Section 72G requires that nurses who have reasonable cause to suspect patient or resident abuse, neglect, mistreatment, and/or misappropriation of their property must report the situation. As stated in 105 CMR 155.003, abuse includes:

What happens if a physician fails to report a child’s injuries?

When a physician is faced with possible cases of child abuse, that physician must report the injuries to the proper authorities. The failure to do so may lead to criminal sanctions, as well as claims of negligence if the child is further injured.

image

What is the nurse's role in reporting the suspected abuse?

For nurses being a mandated reporter means that it is a nurse's responsibility to report any suspicions of child or adult abuse or neglect. If the story just doesn't fit, the nurse needs to be suspicious. If the child or adult suggest they have been abused, the nurse needs to report.

What constitutes neglect of a patient?

Neglect includes the failure to properly attend to the needs and care of a patient, or the unintentional causing of injury to a patient, whether by act or omission.

What happens if a nurse abuses a patient?

As mandated, they are trained to identify signs and symptoms of abuse or neglect and are required by law to report their findings. Failure to do so may result in discipline by the board of nursing, discipline by their employer, and possible legal action taken against them.

Does California law allow you to hand over reporting to another individual?

Neither can mandated reporters hand this responsibility over to another staff member. Mandated reporters must report the incident themselves, they must follow through and no one can alter this legal responsibility.

What is the danger of disregarding the patient's complaint?

By continuously ignoring patient complaints, you send the message that your practice doesn't really care about its patients and their experience. As a result, patients may start to feel undervalued and search for a different practice.

What is considered client abuse?

Intentional or negligent acts by caregivers that result in harm to patients are considered patient abuse. If your loved one experienced abuse in a nursing home facility, a personal injury lawyer may be able to help you. Your loved one may be entitled to compensation.

What can I do about abusive patients?

Here are a few tips to help you manage verbally abusive patients.Be Polite but Firm. When a patient has recurrent abusive behaviors or makes inappropriate comments, address the issue as soon as it occurs. ... Walk Away. ... Question the Reason Behind the Behavior. ... Call Security.

Can a nurse sue a patient for physical abuse?

For a patient that attacks and injures the nurse, he or she can sue the patient and either obtain awards through insurance or by a direct attack on the person. However, the facility that has protections in place may not ensure the prevention of such incidents.

What do doctors do if they suspect abuse?

Discuss any suspicion of abuse sensitively with the patient, whether or not reporting is legally mandated, and direct the patient to appropriate community resources. Report suspected violence and abuse in keeping with applicable requirements.

What is a mandated reporter California?

Who are Mandated Reporters? Any person who is required by law to report a particular category or type of abuse to the appropriate law enforcement or social service agency. • Mandated Reporters are legally responsible to report the incident themselves.

Are nurses mandated reporters in California?

Nurses who work in late-stage care, either in palliative care or in hospice care, should be aware that all nurses, both registered and licensed vocational nurses, are considered mandatory reporters in California.

Does emotional abuse need to be reported?

Especially in cases of child abuse, doctors, teachers, social workers and others who have direct contact with children have a legal obligation to report child abuse, including emotional abuse. (In some states, everyone is a mandatory reporter when it comes to child abuse.)

What is the liability of a physician for failing to report child abuse?

The liability that a physician may have for failing to diagnose and report suspected child abuse depends on the physician's practice location. Most states provide criminal sanctions without providing patients an opportunity to recover damages. Some states, such as New York [5] and Colorado [6], expressly allow recovery for a willful and knowing failure to report (which raises the question of what constitutes "willful and knowing"). Other states, as Becker illustrates, do not allow recovery of damages under a statute, but permit the statute to be used as evidence in a negligence lawsuit of what the physician should have done.

What happens if a plaintiff proves that the defendants violated the mandatory abuse reporting statute?

If a California plaintiff can prove at trial that the defendants in the case violated any state statute-such as the mandatory abuse reporting statute-and that the violation caused injury, the plaintiff has established a basis for civil liability.

What was the case in Landeros v. Flood?

Flood, the California Supreme Court was faced with the question of whether a physician could be held liable for failing to diagnose battered child syndrome (BCS) and reporting the diagnosis to law enforcement authorities. An 11-month-old child was taken to the hospital and examined by the defendant physician, Dr. Flood [1]. Baby Landeros had a fracture in her leg that appeared to be have been caused by a twisting force, bruises covering her back, and a fracture of the skull (that was undiagnosed by Dr. Flood). The infant's mother had no explanation for the injuries. Baby Landeros exhibited other symptoms of BCS: in addition to the injuries, she became fearful and apprehensive when approached by Flood.

Why did the Becker trial court not allow the child abuse reporting statute to be introduced?

Because the child abuse reporting statute had no provision for civil penalties, the Becker trial court did not allow that statute to be introduced. The Minnesota Supreme Court likewise determined that there was no statutory duty owed by the hospital to Nykkole for which she could recover directly under the statute.

What are the exceptions to preserving patient confidentiality?

There are many legal exceptions to preserving patient confidentiality-statutory and court-made. Physicians are required by law to report communicable diseases, to impose quarantine or isolation, and to report suspected violent acts such as gunshot wounds. Mandating that physicians breach confidentiality forces them to act as agents of the state, ...

What is a physician reporting role?

In many of these reporting roles, physicians are acting on behalf of third parties or the public in general. Some of the reports, however, serve the patient directly, and the failure to report may lead to legal action brought on behalf of the patients who allege harm. Indirectly mandatory child abuse reporting laws serve ...

What does it mean to prove that a physician did not meet the standard of care?

Proving only that the physician's treatment did not meet the standard of care is insufficient; a plaintiff must prove further that the failure to provide standard care caused the injuries received after the original examination.

What happens if you don't report abuse?

If you fail to make oral and written reports required by this law to report witnessed or suspected abuse or neglect of a person with a disability, you will be subject to a fine up to $1,000.

What is abuse in CMR?

Board regulations define abuse as any impermissible or unjustifiable contact or communication with a patient which in any way harms or intimidates, or is likely to harm or intimidate, a patient. Abuse may be verbal or non-verbal, and may cause physical, sexual, mental, or emotional harm as stated in 244 CMR 9.02.

What is the law on nursing home abuse?

Massachusetts General Law, Chapter 111, Section 72G requires that nurses who have reasonable cause to suspect patient or resident abuse, neglect, mistreatment, and/or misappropriation of their property must report the situation.

What is the law in Massachusetts for child abuse?

Massachusetts General Law, Chapter 119, Section 51A requires that nurses who have reasonable cause to believe that a child is suffering physical or emotional injury resulting from: Abuse inflicted which causes harm or substantial risk of harm to the child’s health or welfare, including sexual abuse.

What is mandatory nursing reporting?

Several Massachusetts laws and regulations have specific requirements for nurses to report suspected patient abuse, child abuse, elder abuse, and abuse of a disabled person to their respective divisions in State Government. Skip table of contents.

What is the fine for DPH?

DPH will report to the Attorney General and the appropriate registration board. Punishment for failing to make a required oral or written report of suspected abuse is a fine of up to $1,000 and disciplinary action by the board.

What age can you report abuse of a disabled person?

Abuse of persons with disabilities includes acts of physical, sexual, emotional, verbal abuse, and omission by a caregiver of a person with a physical disability between the ages of 18 - 59. Abuse of persons with disabilities under age 18 must be reported as child abuse and if older than 59 as elder abuse (see above).

Why are nursing homes reluctant to report abuse?

The predominant reason why nursing homes can be reluctant to report abuse externally seems to be the fear-inducing nature of the safeguarding response. Interviewees explained how this response tends to presume guilt, and assume allegations of abuse are true before anything is proven.

What did owners and managers think about safeguarding?

Owners and managers thought these two characteristics of safeguarding responses deterred people from reporting incidents and were driving abuse further “underground”.

Is abuse always reported internally?

The outcomes of an empirical research study (Moore, 2017) indicate that abuse is far from being always reported, internally or externally, and that it is sometimes deliberately concealed from outsiders such as relatives and external agencies.

Is abuse in nursing homes always reported?

An empirical research study found that abuse in nursing homes is not always reported, and sometimes it is deliberately concealed. Nursing and care staff replying anonymously to a questionnaire revealed that they were often under pressure to keep quiet about abuse.

What happens if a reporter fails to report child abuse?

A failure to report child abuse can lead to severe consequences including a fine or time in prison for the reporter. Beyond the legal ramifications of a failure to report, not doing this crucial duty can lead to the injury or even the death of the child.

How much is a fine for failing to report abuse in Florida?

Higher Education in Florida: Universities may face a fine of up to $1 million dollars for failure to report or for preventing any person from reporting an instance of abuse committed on the property or an event sponsored by the institution.

How many states have a penalty for reporting child abuse?

The Frightening Consequences of a Mandated Reporter Failing to Report. Almost Every State Imposes a Penalty. Approximately 49 states impose a penalty for failure to report child abuse for mandated reporters, as well as the District of Columbia, American Samoa, Guam, the Northern Mariana Islands, Puerto Rico, and the Virgin Islands.

What is a child abuse agency in Maryland?

Agencies in Maryland: Agencies participating in a child abuse or neglect investigation that have reason to suspect a health care worker, police officer, or educator has failed to report must file a complaint with the appropriate licensing authority.

Which states have harsher penalties for failure to report?

California and Maryland: Penalties may be harsher when the failure to report leads to death or bodily injury. Louisiana: When the case involves sexual abuse or serious injury. Delaware and Virginia: When it’s a second or subsequent failure. Vermont: When the reporter willfully fails to report with the intent to conceal.

Which states don't have penalties for failing to report abuse?

The only state that doesn't specify a penalty for failing to report suspected abuse is Wyoming. 20 U.S. states, the District of Columbia, Guam, the Northern Mariana Island , and the Virgin Islands specify the penalties for a failure to report.

Is failure to report a felony in Arizona?

Arizona: A failure to report may be upgraded to a felony in Arizona if it deals with a serious offense such as prostitution or incest. Minnesota: In Minnesota, the charge may be upgraded if a child dies because of a lack of medical care.

What should a nurse do when treating a patient?

Nurses should provide a calm, comforting environment and approach the patient with care and concern. A complete head-to-toe examination should take place, looking for physical signs of abuse. A chaperone or witness should be present if possible as well.

What is the mandate of a nurse?

As mandated, they are trained to identify signs and symptoms of abuse or neglect and are required by law to report their findings. Failure to do so may result in discipline by the board of nursing, discipline by their employer, and possible legal action taken against them. If a nurse suspects abuse or neglect, they should first report it ...

Do nurses have a responsibility to care for victims of abuse?

Employers are typically clear with outlining requirements for their workers, but nurses have a responsibility to know what to do in case they care for a victim of abuse.

Should a nurse report abuse?

The nurse should notify law enforcement as soon as possible, while the victim is still in the care area. However, this depends on the victim and type of abuse. Adults who are alert and oriented and capable of their decision-making can choose not to report on their own and opt to leave. Depending on the state, nurses may be required ...

Do nurses have to be able to connect victims of abuse?

While not required by law, nurses should also offer to connect victims of abuse to counseling services. Many times, victims fall into a cycle of abuse which is difficult to escape.

Why does Gretchen need to report abuse?

If Carly had younger siblings living with her father, for instance, she might need to report the abuse in order to protect the children. If Carly lived in a state that legally required social workers to report past abuse ...

Does Gretchen allow Carly to report abuse?

On balance, given the facts of the case as interpreted by Gretchen, she decides to permit Carly to decide whether or not to report the abuse. This course of action not only respects Carly’s rights to self-determination and privacy, but also affords Gretchen with the opportunity of continuing to work with Carly.

image